Article review

1) Article Information

Basic information about the article.

Author(s) *

Article Title *

2) Article Evaluation *

Each question requires an answer. A comment is required if the answer is "No" (except Q3).

Does the article title reflect its content?

Q1

Yes No

Comment on the criterion (Q1)

Is the article original?

Q2

Yes No

Comment on the criterion (Q2)

Is the article a review paper?

Q3

Yes No

Are the assumptions stated in the article fulfilled?

Q4

Yes No

Comment on the criterion (Q4)

Do the tables and figures appropriately supplement the work?

Q5

Yes No

Comment on the criterion (Q5)

Are the data in the tables and figures properly prepared?

Q6

Yes No

Comment on the criterion (Q6)

Is the discussion of the research results correct and sufficient?

Q7

Yes No

Comment on the criterion (Q7)

Is the scope and type of cited literature sufficient and appropriate for the article's subject?

Q8

Yes No

Comment on the criterion (Q8)

Are the conclusions correctly formulated and well supported?

Q9

Yes No

Comment on the criterion (Q9)

Is the language quality of the manuscript appropriate?

Q10

Yes No

Comment on the criterion (Q10)

Evaluation Summary (Q1–Q10)

Complete answers to questions Q1–Q10.

Yes: 0 No: 0 Missing: 10

0%

3) Recommendation *

Choose recommendation.

Reviewer recommendation

Suitable for publication as is

No changes required.

Suitable for publication after minor revisions

Minor revisions that do not require restructuring the manuscript.

Suitable for publication after major revisions

Substantial changes required (e.g., methodology, discussion, structure).

Not suitable for publication

Recommendation to reject the manuscript in its current form.

4) General Comments

Comments for authors and editors.

Comments for authors and editors

Comments for editors only (not shared with authors)

5) Conflict of Interest *

Select "Yes" or "No". If "Yes", a comment is required.

Is there a conflict of interest? *

No Yes

Explanation of the potential conflict

6) Reviewer Information

Identification data of the reviewer.

Reviewer *

Review Date *

7) Attachment

Optionally attach a file.

Choose file No file selected

Allowed file formats: PDF/DOC/DOCX/ODT/RTF/TXT/ZIP/RAR/7Z/JPG/PNG.

Article Review

Required fields are marked with an asterisk *.

1) Article Information

2) Article Evaluation *

Evaluation Summary (Q1–Q10)

3) Recommendation *

4) General Comments

5) Conflict of Interest *

6) Reviewer Information

7) Attachment

Popular in 2025